All Your Hardware Needs In One Place!

Welcome to Your Favorite Hardware Store

in Downtown Cleveland

Aisle in a hardware store with power tools on the left and paint cans and supplies on the right.

All Your Hardware Needs in One Place

For more than half a century, Sutton Industrial Hardware and Tool Rental has been Cleveland's premier commercial and residential hardware supplier. Located at 3848 Prospect Ave. in the heart of Cleveland, we serve homeowners, contractors, handymen, and commercial businesses throughout the Cleveland metro area with the products, knowledge, and personal service that the big-box stores simply can't offer.


Our 20,000-square-foot facility is stocked with everything you need to get the job done — from fasteners and electrical supplies to Benjamin Moore paint, Rust-Oleum products, power tools, and much more. Our staff averages over 25 years of experience in commercial and residential hardware sales. When you have a question, you'll get a real answer from someone who knows.


What We Offer


Benjamin Moore Paint — Authorized Dealer

Sutton Industrial Hardware is a proud authorized dealer of Benjamin Moore paint — one of the most trusted names in premium interior and exterior paints. Whether you're touching up a room or taking on a full exterior repaint, our knowledgeable staff will help you choose the right product, sheen, and color to get the result you're after.

Rust-Oleum Products

We carry a full line of Rust-Oleum coatings, primers, and specialty finishes — ideal for metal, wood, concrete, and a wide range of surfaces. From rust prevention to decorative finishes, Rust-Oleum products are a go-to for contractors and DIYers alike.

Deck Stains

Protect and beautify your outdoor wood surfaces with our selection of deck stains. We carry semi-transparent and solid stain options in a range of colors — and our staff can help you choose the right product based on your deck's condition, wood type, and the finish you're looking for.

Tools — Sales and Rental

We carry a full line of Bosch, DeWalt, Porter Cable, and Metabo corded and cordless power tools, as well as a comprehensive hand tool selection. Need a tool for a one-time job? Our tool rental program gives you access to professional-grade equipment without the full purchase price.

Full Hardware Selection

From fasteners and plumbing to electrical, heating, cleaning supplies, and seasonal items — Sutton Hardware carries it all. We stock hard-to-find items you won't see at the national chains, and our experienced staff knows the product lines well enough to help you track down exactly what you need.


Serving Cleveland & Surrounding Areas

We serve contractors, businesses, handymen, and consumers throughout Cleveland, Ohio and the surrounding communities. Whether your project is large or small, bring it to us — we can handle orders of any size and help you navigate from start to finish.


Store Hours

Monday – Friday: 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Saturday – Sunday: Closed

What Our Customers Say

Read reviews from our happy clients

Loading reviews...

Visit Us at 3848 Prospect Ave., Cleveland, OH